Ask me that twenty years ago, and I'm not sure what I would have said. Today I can say "yeah, we've done that,"and we've done it with success.
Working in educational theater presents enough challenges for the ordinary director. Working with kids who have no challenges to speak of is enough for most of us. When we're faced with working with kids who have more severe challenges, we're faced with change, and creative thinking, and ... well, I'm not sure what we call it. At times if feels like panic, fear, worry, or anything else but opportunity.
And that's exactly what it is.
In the 19 years that I've been teaching at my school, our theater has been graced by two blind students, not quite a dozen deaf students (some profoundly, others functionally), four students with Downs Syndrome, three kids in wheelchairs (strangely enough, all three with acute rheumatoid arthritis), several with varying degrees of Asbergers ... and we've always tried to give them a shot and doing theater. Aside from it being "the right thing to do," it would often give we directors as well as our veteran theater students the opportunity to work with kids that we wouldn't work with otherwise. We have yet to have anyone come away from these experiences thinking that it was a mistake.
That's the warm-fuzzy part of this: the kids get a chance to learn from each other. You don't need a stack of research to prove that - it's plainly obvious to even the casual observer. It raises the question, though, regarding what we provide: as instructors, are we doing enough to provide a quality educational experience?
Universal Design for Learning (UDL) is a framework for the structure of instruction for those who need assistive learning - whether that is through technology, the help of an assistant, or the use of materials designed to assist. It provides us with guidance and presses us to think through a lot more scenarios than what we're probably used to.
A particularly challenging moment for me as a theater educator was several years ago when a deaf student wanted to help with sound. The mechanical part was easy - you don't really have to hear to make cable connections and flip on switches. The array of lights and indicators tell you when things are plugged in correctly. But how did she know that the mic worked? You have to hear that, right?
Sort of.
With the help of an interpreter, she was able work with another hearing student - but that was his hearing interpretation of the sound, not her deaf interpretation. She really didn't perform the sound check - it was someone else doing it and then telling her the mic was working. So how can a deaf person work in a theatrical sound environment?
Welcome to the 21st Century, and meet industrial designer Frederick Podzuweit. He has envisioned a collar called "Music For Deaf People" (MFDP) that allows deaf people to experience music. It looks something like this:
It plugs in to a sound device much like a set of headphones, except instead of the signal running to transducer speakers, it runs to a series of membranes that vibrate, expand and contract with the beat and frequency of the sound source. The neck and shoulders receive the tactile sensation, and therefore create a relationship between the intended sound and the sensation of the collar. This allows a deaf person to experience and sense sound by way of the sense of touch.
Suddenly here is a device that solves the dilemma. By connecting this to a sound output device (a sound mixer, iPod, speaker, wireless receiver, etc) my deaf student could do a sound check alone (or at least without the help of an interpreter.) How would the MFDP be used in the classroom? Here is one possible lesson scenario using my Stage Design class as an example.
(UPDATE: Sadly, this is only a conceptual design and not a reality - yet. If only I were good with tools, electronics and pneumatic actuators ...)
A particularly challenging moment for me as a theater educator was several years ago when a deaf student wanted to help with sound. The mechanical part was easy - you don't really have to hear to make cable connections and flip on switches. The array of lights and indicators tell you when things are plugged in correctly. But how did she know that the mic worked? You have to hear that, right?
Sort of.
With the help of an interpreter, she was able work with another hearing student - but that was his hearing interpretation of the sound, not her deaf interpretation. She really didn't perform the sound check - it was someone else doing it and then telling her the mic was working. So how can a deaf person work in a theatrical sound environment?
Welcome to the 21st Century, and meet industrial designer Frederick Podzuweit. He has envisioned a collar called "Music For Deaf People" (MFDP) that allows deaf people to experience music. It looks something like this:
Podzuweit, F (2010). Music for Deaf People device. |
It plugs in to a sound device much like a set of headphones, except instead of the signal running to transducer speakers, it runs to a series of membranes that vibrate, expand and contract with the beat and frequency of the sound source. The neck and shoulders receive the tactile sensation, and therefore create a relationship between the intended sound and the sensation of the collar. This allows a deaf person to experience and sense sound by way of the sense of touch.
Suddenly here is a device that solves the dilemma. By connecting this to a sound output device (a sound mixer, iPod, speaker, wireless receiver, etc) my deaf student could do a sound check alone (or at least without the help of an interpreter.) How would the MFDP be used in the classroom? Here is one possible lesson scenario using my Stage Design class as an example.
(UPDATE: Sadly, this is only a conceptual design and not a reality - yet. If only I were good with tools, electronics and pneumatic actuators ...)
Still not convinced that deaf people can perform in the sound-rich environment of theater? Evelyn Glennie is a fantastic example of how a deaf person can still hear sound and perform music. This is her TedTalks presentation from 2003:
We live in a great age - our technology is allowing for more and better opportunities for students, be it in the arts or the math class. We need to keep looking for ways that allow them to learn better, and allow us to teach them better.
Wow! This tech is amazing...and wonderful! It's amazing that deaf students can be integrated into something that seems so dependent of hearing skills. Good for you for researching and knowing what can help these students. Your lesson plan is extensive...great job!
ReplyDeleteVery encouraging. I love the idea of inclusiveness. A few years ago we had a deaf young lady join our program. It was a huge teachable moment for our staff because we were forced to be very conscious in training preparation, slowing rate of speech for interpreters, etc. Also, as the resident techie on staff I was exposed to lots of cool assistive technologies available to the hearing impaired. It was a learning experience that changed me forever.
ReplyDeleteGreat post, Bill! As always, the difference you are making is inspiring. It would be so interesting to watch one of your productions move through the entire creative process - from selection to performance. By the way...I'm very impressed with the number of visitors to your blog!!
ReplyDeleteBeautiful! Being a percussionist myself, your video really resonated with me. As for what you do with your students, nothing short of inspiring. It is refreshing to hear "why not?" instead of "not possible." I am sure you have made such a positive impact on those students' lives, making them feel like they can do anything they set their minds to.
ReplyDeleteI think that you were correct last night in saying that the collar is not in production yet. I have looked and looked for the device online, to no avail. About the inclusion of students, the manner in which you accomplish this is incredible. I find that what you have done is inspirational and something to be held as an example for all teachers. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteHi William:
ReplyDeleteOn the same train of thought to the idea of a collar device for hearing impaired individuals, speaking impaired individuals and those with Cerebral Palsy now have a device that allows them to talk! The program: "How Was School Today?" is designed along with a divice attached to wheel chairs, with swipe cards & sensors. Anyway, here is the link to an article I found regarding this subject:
http://www.heraldscotland.com/scientists-new-device-gives-gift-of-speech-to-children-unable-to-talk-1.911881
Thank you William for sharing your views on UDL, they were thoughtful and very well researched!
Candyce